Beyond Hatred (Au-delà de la Haine) first published by Film4
Summary: In Olivier Meyrou’s feature-length documentary, justice is restored as two parents transcend their anger and hatred towards the young men who murdered their son.
Review: On 13 September, 2002, a self-assured gay man out walking alone in a park in Reims, France, was set upon, severely beaten and ultimately drowned by three skinheads who had targeted him after failing to find an Arab to “do”. Yet while this random hate crime is the springboard for Olivier Meyrou’s Beyond Hatred (Au-dela de la Haine), the documentary never shows any images of either the victim, François Chenu, or indeed of the three perpetrators, Michael Regnier, Fabien Lavenus or Franck Billette – for this film is less concerned with the brutal act itself, than with the process, both judicial and psychological, whereby hatred is overcome and humanity restored.
Named to suggest that it is both response and spiritual sequel to Mathieu Kassovitz‘s La Haine (1995), Beyond Hatred documents the period before, during and after the murder trial, some two years after the crime was committed. Meyrou had originally intended, by following the prosecution and defense teams, to explore the mechanics of homophobia – but then the Chenu family agreed to let themselves be filmed, and a much broader story began to take shape.
The father Jean-Paul, the mother Marie-Cécile and sister Aurélie discuss their first, shocked reactions to the news of François’ death, and their ongoing grief and suffering, while Marie-Cécile describes with disarming candour her mixed feelings about abandoning the hatred that has been sustaining her ever since. Although during the trial the three accused show little sign of remorse for what they freely admit that they have done, in the end, in an act of extraordinary courage, principle and dignity, François’ parents decide to reach out to their son’s killers, offering understanding, support, and something like forgiveness.
“Is the hardest thing thinking that as he resisted he suffered?” Halfway through Beyond Hatred, as the three-day trial is underway, Aurélie is shown facing this question from Radio France reporter Monique Derrien. The question’s painful insensitivity captures the crude sensationalism which the French media in general brought to bear on their coverage of the case – but it also provides a striking contrast to Meyrou’s own approach in the film. Here the Chenu family are allowed to speak uninterrupted and at length, or are shown in intimate conversation, with the cameras kept at a respectful distance. The interviews are characterised by a grim calm, and often played over quiet, static shots of the Léo Legrange Park where the crime took place. Totally absent is even a hint of tabloid hysteria. Even François-Eudes Chanfrault’s sombre soundtrack of strings and piano is unintrusive.
Meyrou also displays a kind of even-handedness rarely seen in the reportage of violent crime. With the sole exception of the Procuror General, none of the interviewees is identified in a caption, so that the words of the assailants’ relatives, including a father who was himself tried for concealing evidence, receive the same, unprejudiced hearing as those of the victim’s family. The defense lawyers for the perpetrators, far from being glibly caricatured as amoral money-chasers, are shown as earnest, ethically driven individuals who genuinely want the same thing as the prosecution – to bring their clients “back into the fold” of humanity – and who make sincere and sympathetic efforts to build bridges with the aggrieved parties. Perhaps the greatest surprise is that the attorney for the youngest of the self-confessed Arab-haters is himself Arabic. Maroud Benkoussa’s stated aim to bring his client “closer to us” runs in parallel to the reintegrative journey of François’ parents, and is just as moving.
The resulting film is a contemplative, almost poetic examination of the proper workings of justice, and an exemplary depiction of a ruined family rebuilt on the foundations of its own humanistic values. Only rarely can something so good be born of such terrible tragedy.
Verdict: Olivier Meyrou’s balanced courtroom documentary is an extraordinarily calm study of the road leading from hate and grief to justice and reconciliation.
Anton Bitel
