Mary Shelley’s 1818 novel has been Guillermo del Toro’s favourite book since childhood, so this is the film that he has wanted to make his entire life (and has at least partially made with several of his previous films). This is more faithful to the novel than most film adaptations, but del Toro still invents details of his own – like the arms dealer Heinrich Harlander (Christoph Walz) who finances the experiments of Victor Frankenstein (Oscar Isaac), or the status of Elizabeth (Mia Goth) as fiancée to Victor’s younger brother William (Felix Kammerer) rather than to Victor himself, or indeed the details of her character and fate, or the creature’s regenerative powers which make him more superhero or immortal god than monster.
For the most part, though, this is a film about the twisted legacy of family, and the quixotic attempt to rise above that. Young Victor (Christian Convery) is raised with love by his mother Claire (also Goth) and with loveless sadism by his father Leopold (Charles Dance), implanting in him an Oedipal conflict that drives him as an adult to be attracted to the woman who resembles (and is indeed like) his mother, and to wish to outdo his father in both medical research and callousness. So when, in the gothic ruins of a water tower, Victor births his creature (Jacob Elordi), he treats it with the same objectifying disdain that his own father showed him – and the monster, seeking only to be loved, quickly learns, as Victor had done, to hate.
Over decades and across continents, this arrogant father and his confused son – both literally scarred by their experiences – will come into repeated, vicious conflict, and find hateful revenge, or just possibly that most elusive state of grace, forgiveness. This myth of scientific hubris and familial dysfunction resonates with any age – but only del Toro could make something so sweepingly grand, so exquisitely beautiful and so full of passion and pathos as this. All the immaculate production design, stunningly stylised costumes and glorious practical effects look a treat, as Shelley’s monstrous legacy is resurrected and eternalised.
strap: Guillermo del Toro’s spectacularly baroque adaptation of Mary Shelley is an Oedipal tale of loved mothers, hated fathers and lost sons
© Anton Bitel
